The three things they're judging, and none of them is your wardrobe

You can recognize executive presence by the feedback nobody bothers to explain. Someone tells you that you need more of it, no one can explain what it looks like, and before long you are second-guessing your jacket. Pause there. Those judging it are really weighing three things: whether they can trust you with a decision, whether your words land when you speak, and whether you hold steady when things fall apart. Your clothing plays no part. The fuzziness is deliberate in a sense. Studies on the likability penalty have repeatedly shown that the same request is read as assertive when a man makes it and as demanding when a woman does, and "presence" is the label that conveniently hides that bias.

The review

Looking back over the last month, reply with a plain yes or no. Count only what actually happened, not what you imagine you would have done.

Step 1. Lead with the conclusion you're recommending, then walk through the rationale behind it.

Step 2. In a meeting, you openly challenged a more senior colleague.

Step 3. Your team's mission should fit into one sentence that someone from Towson or Ellicott City could repeat back to you.

Step 4. Whenever something falls apart, colleagues tend to bring it to you first, ahead of anyone else in the chain.

Step 5. Rather than scrambling to fill a silence during a meeting, you let it sit.

Step 6. You said "I don't know, and I'll find out by Thursday," and then actually did.

Step 7. The notes you send senior leaders in Columbia and Owings Mills are briefer than the ones they send back to you.

Step 8. When a senior leader asked something of you that you couldn't take on, you declined in one sentence and explained why.

Step 9. Even in a room that was falling apart, you kept a steady, composed appearance.

Final step. At a later meeting, someone echoed one of your own lines back to the group.

Reading your score

Eight to ten: well established across Central Maryland. Colleagues in the room already regard you as a person who decides things. If you still receive the feedback, ask who is offering it and what they really mean, because it may have little to do with you.

Four to seven: taking shape. You possess the judgment, and you're partway to showing it. Most of what is missing is speed and economy: the recommendation up front, the tighter email, the pause you let stand while the room catches up.

Zero to three: competent but reserved. You're producing the work and leaving others to figure out what it amounts to. That is not a character flaw. Many of us were trained to show our reasoning before earning the conclusion, which is sound advice for a classroom but not for a boardroom.

Your following step

If you score eight to ten, the next time someone brings up "presence," ask them, "What specifically would you want to see differently in the next meeting?" and jot down what they say. When nobody can answer that question, the lesson is about how the feedback was given, not about you.

A four to seven calls for a month-long habit: start every update in Dundalk or Essex, or anywhere else, with the decision you need in the opening sentence. Change nothing else. Notice how the room responds.

Zero to three: in your next meeting, disagree once, briefly, with the most senior person present, then stop talking. Keep it simple by saying, "I see it differently, and here's why," and then give others room to reply. The quiet that comes afterward is where your influence lives.

Count your yeses, and pass this along to the woman who was told she needs more presence and never learned what that meant.